meallanfearghail's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Royal March]

It does not sound like a Royal March at all.

It sounds to me more like a ballroom or breakdance piece rather than a processional march, which should sound more enriched and harmonic. Please listen to the works of G.Händel and C.-F.Gounod and try to learn from them.

Step responds:

OK, thanks for pointing that out, but a song isn't all about the name. Couldn't you tell me a little about the song itself, nextime?

[Symphany No. 1]

Introducing

May I introduce you to MaestroRage and MilkmanDan, who may consider to teach you how to compose a symphony instead of a cacophony?

NoHost responds:

may i introduce to you dese nuts

[This Is Halloween {Alix1}]

Fantasia!

I'm pretty sure that this is live.

alix1 responds:

I did parts of i live on my MIDI piano. Im not too good at the piano though :(
I did just the easy parts. thanks for the ten!
--Alix1

[Judgement at Heaven Gate]

You have potential, brother.

I can see you DO have potential powers in composing. Keep up your good work and do more improvement, brother.

Turning 19
Love Linguistics and Literature

Respect.

dontxthemusic responds:

I'm a Chick. LOL. XD So how about sister instead :P And thank you very much ^_^ I hope to keep improving. I just need to get the hang of doing this...

[Pictures at an Exhibition [B]]

This is plagiarism!

For Gods' sake, don't do this again.
0/5 and 0/10.

Vexorian responds:

Plagiarism would be me claiming this as my own work...

Which I have clearly stated this is was composed by Modest Mussorgsky.

[Looking Back (short version)]

Your piece works.

It gave me courage to re-think about why my past was so sad, instead of simply feeling sad of it.You deserve 5/5 and 10/10.

Respect.

BaronWeasel responds:

Thank you very much for the review and for telling me how this piece made you feel. It's people like you that keep us composers motivated!

[The Piano Song]

Your mood didn't agree with your song?

The song gave me the feeling that you want to express happiness when you're sad - especially when the song suddenly stopped.

Respect.

OvalsinOuterSpace responds:

don't know, i just made it for no reason...

[Hell on Earth 2007]

Armirable courage.

Seldom people had tried to combine classic & R&B & strong beats.
You're a pioneer. But you need more study.

Respect.

Ludzix responds:

Yay XD

[Sonata de la Tormenta]

"Technical"

Not every piano player can play such technical piece.
I apprecialte.

itsameyayo responds:

Actually, it's impossible to play, but I've got to rewrite it so it's possible to play so a friend can play it. Maybe it could be a dual piano piece atm?

-Thanks!

-ImperfectDisciple